I have checked out tons of gel type cases, and usually reject them because they lift the screen, don't stick up off the screen enough or don't seem to fit well overall. I don't take my case on and off a lot so I am not worried about stretching it out from that but I don't want it loose from just putting it on.
I do wish there were more solid colors and less bizarro combinations. I got the husband black with gray and myself purple because the other options were all sorts of fug.
We got ours through ATT store simply because we got a bundle situation but separately it is $35 which is wicked pricey but so far I haven't damaged my phone so I guess that's money well spent.
I also bought a little pouch on SeaSideSew on etsy as well, just as a double layer for when it's in the abyss that is my purse.